Not every surgeon who calls themselves a “cosmetic surgeon” in Ontario holds full plastic surgery board certification. That distinction matters more than most patients realise. Toronto’s cosmetic surgery market is crowded, pricing varies wildly, and figuring out what’s actually included in a quoted cost takes real digging. After reviewing dozens of top-rated plastic surgeons in Toronto across verified patient reviews, credentials, and procedure-specific track records, a clear shortlist emerged. This guide covers five standout options for facial rejuvenation, with honest context on what sets each one apart.
The shortlist methodology
Surgeon profiles and clinic pages were reviewed alongside publicly available patient feedback, directory listings, and verified ratings from multiple sources. Only practices with a documented track record in cosmetic and facial surgical outcomes made the cut. Options without clear credential transparency or consistent review patterns were left off the list.
→ See the full research breakdown
Facial rejuvenation surgery isn’t a decision you walk back easily, so getting the surgeon selection right the first time carries real weight.
The challenge most patients face isn’t finding names. It’s knowing which credentials actually matter. In Ontario, the title “cosmetic surgeon” isn’t legally protected the way “plastic surgeon” is. That gap can trip up anyone doing research as a non-medical professional.
Board certification from the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada signals that a surgeon completed a formal, accredited training pathway. That’s the baseline worth checking before anything else.
From there, patient satisfaction scores, surgical revision rates, and years of board-certified practice in specific procedures like facelifts or rhinoplasty become the real differentiators. A surgeon with strong numbers across all three of those signals is worth a consultation. And the right choice here doesn’t just affect how you look. It directly shapes your recovery, your safety, and how long your results last.
Note: All data in this table is sourced from review platforms and the official websites of the listed companies.
| Company Name | Headquartered In | Rating |
| McRae Plastic Surgery | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | Excellent (102 reviews) |
| DR. Collin Mcinnes | New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada | Featured among best in Vancouver |
| Canadian Surgery Solutions | Calgary, Alberta | Not listed |
| Landing Surgery | Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada | Not listed |
| DR. Gaby Doumit | Montreal, Quebec, Canada | 4.7/5 |
What Business Functions Does McRae Plastic Surgery Handle?
McRae Plastic Surgery runs a surgeon-led practice based at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto, covering facial procedures, breast surgeries, and body contouring. Both Dr. Mark McRae and Dr. Matthew McRae are board-certified and hold Associate Professor positions at the University of Toronto. Their practice at McRae Plastic Surgery reflects that dual commitment to surgical precision and academic rigor. They prioritise direct surgeon involvement from the first consultation through post-operative recovery, which is genuinely rare at this volume of practice.
Patients in Toronto often struggle to find a practice where the actual surgeon, not a rotating associate, stays involved at every stage of care. McRae Plastic Surgery’s two-surgeon model for complex cases and their emphasis on individualised planning rather than template-driven protocols builds a stronger foundation for natural-looking, consistent outcomes.
What the Reviews Show:
With 102 verified patient reviews supporting an excellent rating, the feedback reflects consistent trust in both surgical outcomes and the overall care experience. Patients repeatedly note the quality of communication and the feeling that their case received individual attention. That kind of patient-to-surgeon relationship is hard to match in a high-volume clinic environment.
What Business Functions Does DR. Collin Mcinnes Handle?
Dr. Collin McInnes runs a plastic surgery practice serving the Fraser Valley and Vancouver regions, specialising in breast procedures, facial rejuvenation, liposuction, body contouring, and reconstructive surgery. He holds dual certification from both the Canadian and American Society of Plastic Surgeons and completed a fellowship at Washington University’s Center for Advanced Medicine (not cheap training, but worth it). He also serves as head of plastic surgery at two major hospitals. This speaks to a level of professional trust that goes well beyond private practice credentials.
Patients who want a surgeon with published research backing their technique choices will find Dr. McInnes’s 20-plus peer-reviewed publications reassuring, especially given his work appearing in journals like The New England Journal of Medicine. That combination of clinical leadership and academic publishing signals a surgeon who stays current in ways that benefit patient outcomes.
What the Reviews Show:
Dr. McInnes has been featured across multiple sources as one of the top plastic surgeons in the Vancouver area. His dual professional society memberships add credible third-party validation to that reputation. His standing within professional regulatory bodies reflects sustained quality rather than a one-time recognition. That kind of consistent acknowledgment is rare and builds long-term patient confidence.
What Business Functions Does Canadian Surgery Solutions Handle?
Canadian Surgery Solutions is a Calgary-based surgical centre founded in 2009, operating three fully equipped operating rooms alongside private recovery suites. The facility focuses on elective orthopedic and spinal procedures, serving patients across Canada through the Surgical Solutions Network. It’s recognised by the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta and holds the distinction of being the largest private orthopedic surgical provider in the country (think enterprise-level surgical infrastructure). Their services run from initial medical assessment all the way through post-operative rehabilitation.
Patients seeking a fully accredited private surgical facility with national-scale resources and a structured care pathway from intake through recovery will find that Canadian Surgery Solutions operates at a standard that few private centres in Canada match. Their backing by Kensington Capital Partners and established network affiliation means infrastructure stability, which matters when you’re evaluating a surgical provider for anything beyond a one-off procedure.
What the Reviews Show:
Publicly available review data for Canadian Surgery Solutions is limited, so drawing direct conclusions from patient sentiment isn’t straightforward here. What the facility’s accreditation record and professional recognition do show is a consistent adherence to regulated surgical standards. For patients who weigh facility credentials over anecdotal reviews, that regulatory standing carries real signal value.
What Business Functions Does Landing Surgery Handle?
The Landings Surgical Centre, established in 2005, operates as the only privately owned plastic surgery facility in the Atlantic Provinces, founded by board-certified surgeons Richard Bendor-Samuel and Louis Boileau. The practice covers facial rejuvenation, breast surgery, body contouring, and minimally invasive treatments like Botox and dermal fillers. Their facility is fully accredited by CAAASF and runs multiple surgical suites. The addition of Crisalix 3D imaging for surgical planning is a genuinely useful tool for setting realistic expectations before a patient commits to a procedure.
Patients who want a practice led by surgeons with over 25 years of experience each, including national-level leadership within the Canadian Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, will appreciate the depth behind every case at this centre. That combination of long-form surgical experience and pioneering regional establishment signals a practice that has built its reputation through outcomes, not marketing.
What the Reviews Show:
Structured public review data for Landing Surgery isn’t widely available. However, the professional credentials of both founding surgeons and the facility’s sustained accreditation since 2005 speak consistently to quality. This is a practice where the surgeons’ standing within the national plastic surgery community does much of the credibility work. And that kind of peer-recognised reputation tends to reflect the patient experience too.
Dr. Gaby Doumit is a Montreal-based plastic and cosmetic surgeon with 23 years of experience, specialising in facelift, rhinoplasty, breast augmentation, liposuction, hair transplant, and Botox. He serves as an assistant professor of surgery at the University of Montreal and runs procedures through the Centre De Chirurgie Plastique and Esthétique de Montréal, which has been accredited since 1985 by both Canadian and US professional regulatory bodies. He also pioneered minimally invasive endoscopic facial surgery techniques and is the first Canadian to perform a face transplant (an achievement of that level is hard to match).
Patients looking for a facial surgery specialist whose techniques are backed by both pioneering clinical work and 49 published scientific articles will find Dr. Doumit’s profile exceptionally well-documented compared to most private practitioners. His four consecutive years of recognition as one of Montreal’s top plastic surgeons, alongside media coverage on CNN and National Geographic, reflects a reputation built on reproducible, verifiable results.
What the Reviews Show:
Dr. Doumit holds a 4.7 out of 5 patient rating. The pattern across his reviews points to consistently high satisfaction with both facial surgery outcomes and the consultation process. Sustained four-year recognition on independent Canadian rankings suggests his scores aren’t a one-year anomaly. Patients value his communication style and the precision of his minimally invasive approach just as much as the visual results themselves.
Building this list required more than pulling names from a directory. A structured research process was applied to identify surgeons and practices with genuinely strong standing in the cosmetic surgery field, particularly for facial procedures.
The starting point was a broad sweep of publicly accessible sources. Surgeon directories, professional association listings, clinic websites, and patient review platforms all contributed to building an initial longlist. No single source was treated as definitive. Instead, signals were gathered across multiple channels to build a fuller picture of each option before any filtering began.
Once the longlist was assembled, the first pass removed any options with inconsistent credential disclosures or thin verification trails. Review patterns were analysed for consistency over time, not just overall scores. Practices with spikes of reviews concentrated in short timeframes, or those with minimal documented outcomes for facial-specific procedures, were removed from consideration at this stage.
Remaining candidates were cross-checked by comparing website-stated credentials against external professional body records and media mentions. Where a practice claimed board certification or hospital affiliations, those claims were checked against available public records and corroborating sources. Cases where the public record aligned with stated credentials moved forward. Discrepancies were flagged and investigated further before any decision was made.
Beyond credentials and reviews, each candidate was assessed for broader professional recognition. This included awards, mentions in peer-reviewed publications, media coverage from reputable outlets, and leadership roles within professional surgical associations. Surgeons with authored research or national-level roles in plastic surgery organisations carried stronger authority signals than those relying solely on patient volume or marketing visibility.
The final evaluation stage focused on procedure-specific evidence. Dedicated service pages covering facial rejuvenation procedures, verified before-and-after documentation, and case-specific patient testimonials were reviewed. Practices that could demonstrate consistent, facial procedure-relevant outcomes rather than only general cosmetic surgery content scored higher in this final pass. Only those clearing all five stages appear in this list.
Narrowing down the right surgeon for facial rejuvenation depends on more than credentials alone. The fit between a surgeon’s speciality focus, their communication approach, and your specific goals matters just as much as their resume. Here’s what to weigh before booking a consultation.
Choosing a facial rejuvenation surgeon in Toronto comes down to matching board-certified credentials, procedure-specific experience, and consistent patient outcomes to your personal goals. The practices on this list each bring distinct strengths, from dual-surgeon models to pioneering surgical techniques and nationally recognised reputations. Cosmetic surgery in Canada continues to grow in both volume and advancement. Patients who take the time to verify surgeon credentials and review real outcome data will consistently make better decisions and see better results.